Parvaneh Sharifi; Alireza Manzari Tavakoli; Mitra Kamyabi; Zahra Zeinaddiny Meymand
Abstract
Background: Program accreditation is a quality assurance educational program implemented in many countries.Objectives: This study aimed to compare program accreditation standards of the Ministry of Health of Iran with several selected countries and to extract program accreditation standards to benefit ...
Read More
Background: Program accreditation is a quality assurance educational program implemented in many countries.Objectives: This study aimed to compare program accreditation standards of the Ministry of Health of Iran with several selected countries and to extract program accreditation standards to benefit from the experiences of other countries.Methods: The present descriptive-comparative study was performed in 2020. The information required for the study was collected by searching on the Internet on valid websites of accreditation institutes of medical sciences and higher education in Iran and other countries. Among them, the World Federation for Medical Education (WFME) program accreditation standards and eight countries from different continents were compared with Iran. The research was conducted using the Beredy model.Results: The results showed that the standards in the studied programs were significantly different both quantitatively and qualitatively. It was also found that the accreditation standards of educational programs in Iran, Kazakhstan, and the WFME were consistent regarding the areas’ number and titles, but there was a difference in the number and titles of the criteria and indicators.Conclusion: Considering the vital role of graduates of medical sciences in promoting community health and also given the current and particular situation and the global conflict with COVID-19 epidemic, which has disrupted face-to-face education and evaluation at all educational levels, upgrading and improving the quality of medical education programs seems necessary more than ever. Therefore, to evaluate and promote the quality of these programs, it is suggested to codify accreditation standards of educational programs locally and according to the current conditions.
Esmat Noohi; Leila Ghorbani-Gharani; Abbas Abbaszadeh
Volume 12, Issue 3 , November 2015, , Pages 450-471
Abstract
Background & Objective: In order to achieve more success in the Bachelor of Science in the discipline of nursing education in Iran and identify its weaknesses and strengths comparative studies and utilization of successful universities strategies and experiences are necessary The present research ...
Read More
Background & Objective: In order to achieve more success in the Bachelor of Science in the discipline of nursing education in Iran and identify its weaknesses and strengths comparative studies and utilization of successful universities strategies and experiences are necessary The present research compares the curricula of undergraduate nursing education in Iran and 8 selected universities from America Europe Australia and Asia The universities were compared in terms of student selection methods mission and objective general structure program length educational content teaching and learning methods educational strategies role of graduates and evaluation methodologies Methods: This was a descriptivecomparative study In the present study 8 renowned and innovative nursing schools were selected through purposeful sampling method The important components and indices of nursing curricula of the 8 nursing schools in America Europe Australia and Asia were analyzed Then each studied item was compared between the selected nursing schools and nursing schools of Iran Practical suggestions were made to improve the quality of the nursing curriculum in Iran in terms of improvement of each studied item The research model used in this study was the Beredy model that identified the 4 stages of description interpretation proximity and comparison in comparative studies Results: The general objectives and educational contents in all curricula of the examined nursing schools were to some extent similar However the establishment and development of the contents and the method extent and type of addressing them were different These differences created different contents Moreover despite the many similarities in training and evaluation techniques many differences depending on the level and purpose of the program were observed Conclusion: It seems that although the nursing curriculum in Iran does not hold a dissatisfactory position in comparison with the other studied curricula in order to resolve the flaws items like goals selection student selection methods research teaching and evaluation (theory and performance) methodologies need to be reviewed and revised
Hossein Karimi Moonaghi; Roza Montazeri
Volume 11, Issue 4 , February 2015, , Pages 420-433
Abstract
Background & Objective: For greater success of the discipline of medical education and recognition of its weaknesses and strengths performing a comparative study and utilizing the experiences of successful universities is necessary This study was performed to compare the elements of the curricula ...
Read More
Background & Objective: For greater success of the discipline of medical education and recognition of its weaknesses and strengths performing a comparative study and utilizing the experiences of successful universities is necessary This study was performed to compare the elements of the curricula of medical education discipline in the universities of Dundee (Scotland) Calgary (Canada) and Maastricht (Holland) with Iran Methods: Data were gathered by searching university websites and communicating with them The 3 universities of Dundee Calgary and Maastricht which had a high ranking in the medical education major were selected as the study sample The research model used in this study was the Beredy model that specifies the four stages of description interpretation proximity and comparison in comparative studies Results: The universities of Dundee Calgary and Maastricht in stating the general characteristics of curriculum have clearly focused on education in the field of medical sciences Elements of mission vision and value were not observed in their curricula In the universities of Dundee and Maastricht educational strategies and the reason for their application and the manner of course presentation had been explained All 3 universities enrolled bachelor students The course of research in education was emphasized by all universities Conclusion: Based on this comparative study the curriculum of medical education in Iran seems complete and comprehensive However for quality improvement the revision of goals and strategies of the discipline is necessary Moreover the presentation of courses in two forms of virtual and traditional education admission of bachelor (BSc) students replacement of compensatory course with prerequisite courses and emphasizing of research method in education courses are recommended