Strides in Development of Medical Education

The Comparison of Medical Students Attitudes and Performance Regarding Different Types of Academic Cheating During Clinical Courses

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Mitra Amini 1
Marjan Parizad 2
Sara Rivaz 3
Mohammad Mehdi Sagheb 4
Mozhdeh Rivaz 5

1 Ph.D. in Communication Medicine, Associate Professor, Quality Improvement in Clinical Education Research Center, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran

2 General Practitioner, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran

3 M.Sc. in Health Services Administration, Quality Improvement in Clinical Education Research Center, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran

4 Ph.D. in Adult Nephrology, Associate Professor, Quality Improvement in Clinical Education Research Center, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran

5 M.Sc. in Biology, Directorate of Education and Training, Shiraz, Iran

Abstract
Background & Objective: Cheating in the university can be a predictor of workplace fraud and workplace fraud among physicians and specialists will have negative consequences This study was performed for the purpose of determining the prevalence of all kinds of cheating among medical students which were in their last three years of Medical School at Shiraz University of Medical Sciences Iran in 2010 Methods: The study sample consisted of 136 medical students in their last three years of study The participants were selected through simple random sampling The data collection tool was a selfadministered questionnaire The validity of the questionnaire was confirmed by experts and its reliability was reported as 087 in a study Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and independent ttest (for the variable of gender) in SPSS statistical software Results: All students answered the questionnaire; thus the response rate was 100% Among the respondents 64% were male and the rest female According to the results more than 80% of students had experienced copying during an exam at least once during the academic period Moreover 25% of students have performed at least one kind of plagiarism in writing their thesis and essays The performance of medical students in the clinical course showed that 50% of students had cheated at least once during their academic period The rate of cheating was significantly lower in female students Conclusion: Although the majority of students have a positive attitude and believe cheating to be a dishonest action half of them have cheated This may be due to stress caused by examinations Therefore it seems that students behaviors should be changed and they must receive the necessary training in this regard so that stress is not the cause of fraud and this phenomenon is inhibited

Keywords

Plagiarism
cheating
medical student
Morality
  1. Bashir H. University of moral codes. [Cited 2010 Aug 26]. Available from: http://www.hbashir.blogsky.com/1389/06/04/post-156/
  2. Thorpe MF, Reed BD, Pittenger DJ. Cheating the researcher: a study of the relation between personality measures and self-reported cheating. College Student J. 1999; 33(1): 49.
  3. Jensen LA, Felman SS, Cauffman E. It's wrong, but everybody does it: academic dishonesty among high  dchool  and  college  students. Contemporary  Educ  Psychol.  2002;  27(2):  20928.
  4. Haiens  VJ,  Diekhoff  GM,  LaBeff  EE.  College cheating:  Immaturity  Lake  of  commitment,  and the  naturalizing  attitude.  Res  Higher  Educ.  1986; 25(4):  342-54.
  5. Maramuk  S,  Maline  M.  Academic  dishonestly among  college  students.  Issues  in  education: Washington,  DC:  Department  of  Education. Office  of  Educational  Research  an  Improvement. [cited 1993  Aug  8].  Available  from: http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED360903.pdf
  6. Sierles  F,  Hendrickx  I,  Circle  S.  Cheating  of medical  school.  J  Med  Edu.  1980;  55(2): 124-5.
  7. Gaberson  KB.  Academic  dishonestly  among nursing  students.  Nurs  Forum.  1997;  32(3):14-20.
  8. Rozance  CP.  Cheating  in  medical  schools: implications  for  students  and  patients.  JAMA. 1991;  266(17):2453-6. 
  9. Whitley  BE.  Factors  associated  with  cheating among  college  students.  Res  Higher  Educ.  1998; 39(3):  235-74.
  10. Zahedi LN.  Scientific  misconduct  in  conducting medical  research  and  manuscript  writing:  a profession  responsibility.  Ethics  Sci  Technol. 2007; 2(3 [In  Persian] & 4): 73-80.
  11. Smith R.  Cheating  at  medical  school.  BMJ.  2000; 321(7258):  398.
  12. McCabe  DL.  The  influence  of  situational  ethics on  cheating  among  college  student.  Sociological Inquiry.  1992;  62(3):  365-374.
  13. Nakhaee N,  Nikpour  H.  Investigation  of  medical students’  opinions  on  research  fraud  in  thesis  and its  frequency.  J  Strides  Dev  Med  Educ.  2005; 2(1):  10-7.  [In  Persian]
  14. Moeedfar  S.  Students’  pathology  of  Tehran University.  Tehran:  Tehran  University;  2005.  [In Persian]
  15. Shabani A.  Ethical  highlights  to  write  paper.  Iran J  Psychiatry  Clin  Psychol.  2007;  13(2),  87-8.  [In Persian]
  16. Pupovac  V,  Bilic-Zulle  L,  Mavrinac  M, Petrovecki  M.  Attitudes  toward  plagiarism  among pharmacy  and  medical  biochemistry  students cross  –sectional  survey  study.  Biochemica Medica.  2010;  20(3):  307-13.
  17. Ereta  E,  Gokmenoglua  T.  Plagiarism  in  higher education:  A  case  study  with  prospective academicians.  Procedia  Soc  Behav  Sci.  2010; 2(2),  3303–7.
  18. Rennie  SC,  Crosby  JR.  Are  “tomorrow's  doctors” honest?  Questionnaire  study  exploring  medical students'  attitudes  and  reported  behaviour  on academic  misconduct.  BMJ.  2001  Feb  3; 322(7281):  274–275.
  19. Anteneh AD,  Asres  B.  Cheating  on  examinations and  its  predictors  among  undergraduate  students at  Hawassa  University  College  of  Medicine  and Health  Science,  Hawassa,  Ethiopia.  BMC  Med Educ.  2014;  14(1):  89.
  20. Amiri  MA,  Khamesan  A,  Ayati  M.  Honor  Codes in  Higher  Education  Academic:  A  Comparative Study  of  Selected  British,  American  and  Iranian Universities.  Ethics  Sci  Technol.  2011;  6(4):  1720.  [In  Persian]
  21. Spiller S,  Crown  DF.  Changes  over  time  in academic  dishonesty  at  the  collegiate  level. Psychol Rep.  1995; 76(3  Pt 1):763-8.
  22. Murdock  TB,  Hale  NM,  Weber  MJ.  Predictors  of cheating  among  early  adolescents.  Academic  and social  motivations.  Contemp  Educ  Psychol.  2001; 26(1):96-115.
  23. Hollinger  RC,  Lanza-Kaduke  L.  Academic Dishonesty  and  the  Perceived  Effectiveness  of Countermeasures:  An  Empirical  Survey  of Cheating  at  a  Major  Public  University.  NASPA  J. 1996;  33(4): 292-306.
Strides in Development of Medical Education
Volume 12, Issue 5
2016
Pages 709-717

Home

Editorial Policy

Submit Manuscript

Guide for Authors

Peer Review Process

Guide for Reviewers

Publication Ethics Policy

Forms

Suggestion and Complain

FAQ

Contact Us